Jan 22, 2018 | Ari's Favorites

Pimentuna Casserole

Big new hit at the Roadhouse

by Ari Weinzweig

I probably shouldn’t be surprised anymore—the best ideas so often start out as silly jokes. Same here. It began with a bit of light culinary humor and has ended up with what I’m pretty sure is a signature dish in the making.

The whole thing started about six weeks ago with my girlfriend Tammie Gilfoyle’s idea to mix our pimento cheese with tuna. I tried it. She was right: it was delicious. The idea turned into the Pimentuna melt, which has already become a really popular sandwich at the Roadhouse, grilled on one of my favorite Bakehouse breads, the Country Wheat.

Then, a few days or so ago, I made a joke that maybe we should use our new mix to make Pimentuna Casserole. You know, a throwback and takeoff on the tried and true mid-20th-century classic. That sounded a little crazy, too, but about 20 minutes later, what had started as a silly statement was sounding better and better and I decided to make it. Pimentuna Casserole turned out to be really good! And now it’s on the Roadhouse lunch menu.

If you want a bit of tasty comfort on one of these cold winter days, come on in for a taste. It’s our mash-up of West Coast tuna with pimento cheese, tossed with the Martelli family’s marvelous bronze die-extruded maccheroni.

The Roadhouse crew had the great idea to seal the deal by topping the whole thing with a handful of Zingerman’s Tellicherry black pepper potato chips to add some crunch. What can I say? Killer! Comforting. Compelling. Definitely worth coming across town to have for lunch!!

Check out the Roadhouse lunch menu!

Never fear, BBQ is still here!We're still serving up really good American food.

Drive Thru Daily 7am–8pm
Curbside Pick-Up Monday-Friday 11am–8pm // Saturday-Sunday 9am–8pm
Order Online! »

Our dining room is closed until further notice, state's orders. Thanks so much for your support and understanding. Stay safe 'yall!
Read about our COVID-19 updates»